When it comes to SUVs in India, Mahindra has long been a trusted name, delivering robust, dependable vehicles that dominate both city streets and challenging terrains. Two of Mahindra’s best models, the Scorpio and Thar, are quite popular among SUV enthusiasts. But how do these two giants compare? This comprehensive guide dives into every detail of the Scorpio vs Thar debate to help you make an informed decision.
Outlines
Comparision Scorpio vs Thar
| Description | Mahindra Scorpio | Mahindra Thar |
|---|---|---|
| Engine | mHawk Diesel | Petrol: Turbocharged, Diesel |
| Power | 130-175 BHP | Petrol: 150 BHP, Diesel: 130 BHP |
| Torque | 300-400 Nm | Petrol: 300 Nm, Diesel: 300-320 Nm |
| Top Speed | 165-175 km/h | 150-155 km/h |
| Mileage | 15-16 km/l | Petrol: 14 km/l, Diesel: 15.2 km/l |
| Fuel Capacity | 60 liters | 57 liters |
| Fuel Type | Diesel | Petrol and Diesel |
| Brakes | Front Disc, Rear Drum | Disc on All Wheels |
| Tires | 17-inch Radial | 18-inch All-Terrain |
Power
- Mahindra Scorpio: Equipped with a powerful mHawk diesel engine, the Scorpio produces a maximum power output of 130-175 bhp depending on the variant.
- Mahindra Thar: The Thar is powered by both petrol and diesel engines. The petrol variant produces 150 bhp, while the diesel engine produces 130 bhp.
- Comparison: While the Scorpio offers more power in its higher trims, the Thar’s petrol engine offers a spirited performance for thrill seekers.
Torque
- Scorpio: Offers 300-400 Nm of torque, ensuring great pulling power for heavy loads and off-road adventures.
- Thar: Offers 300 Nm (petrol) and 300-320 Nm (diesel), giving it strong off-road capabilities.
- Conclusion: Both SUVs are great in torque delivery, but the higher torque variants of the Scorpio are better for highway drives and towing.
Top Speed Scorpio vs Thar
- Scorpio: Capable of reaching a top speed of 165-175 kmph.
- Thar: Slightly slower with a top speed of 150-155 kmph, designed more for rough terrain than highways.
- Insight: The Scorpio’s higher top speed makes it a better choice for long-distance highway travel.
Mileage
- Scorpio: Offers a mileage of 15-16 kmpl for the diesel variants.
- Thar: The diesel variant offers a mileage of around 15.2 kmpl, while the petrol variant offers a mileage of 14 kmpl.
- Efficiency Comparison: The Scorpio and Thar are almost equal in terms of mileage, but the Scorpio’s slightly better fuel efficiency may attract budget-conscious buyers.
Fuel Capacity
- Scorpio: Has a larger 60-litre fuel tank for long drives.
- Thar: Has a 57-litre fuel tank, which is sufficient for most adventures.
- Conclusion: The Scorpio’s larger tank ensures fewer stops for refuelling on long journeys.
Fuel Type Scorpio vs Thar
- Scorpio: Available in diesel only.
- Thar: Offers both petrol and diesel options, catering to a wide range of choices.
- Highlights: The petrol option of the Thar adds versatility to the lineup.
Brakes
- Scorpio: Comes equipped with ventilated disc brakes at the front and drum brakes at the rear.
- Thar: Comes with disc brakes on all four wheels for great stopping power.
- Safety edge: The all-disc brakes on the Thar offer better braking performance, especially off-road.
Tyres
- Scorpio: Features 17-inch radial tyres to ease on-road performance.
- Thar: Offers larger 18-inch all-terrain tyres, making it ideal for rugged terrains.
- Off-road focus: The tyre setup of the Thar is better suited for adventure expeditions.
Dimensions Scorpio vs Thar
| Description | Mahindra Scorpio | Mahindra Thar |
| Length | 4,456 mm | 3,985 mm |
| Width | 1,820 mm | 1,855 mm |
| Height | 1,995 mm | 1,844 mm |
Length
- Scorpio: Measures 4,456 mm, offering a spacious cabin.
- Thar: Slightly shorter at 3,985 mm, which gives it a compact, rugged look.
- Space comparison: The Scorpio is better suited for families, while the Thar’s shorter length enhances off-road maneuverability.
Width
- Scorpio: Is 1,820 mm, which ensures a stable ride.
- Thar: Measures 1,855 mm, which offers a wider stance for better off-road stability.
- Verdict: The Thar’s width gives it an edge in stability on uneven terrains.
Height
- Scorpio: With a height of 1,995 mm, it offers great road presence.
- Thar: Slightly shorter at 1,844 mm, designed to tackle low-hanging obstacles off-road.
- Comparison: The Scorpio’s taller profile is ideal for urban and highway use, while the Thar’s compact height aids off-road agility.
Engine and Power Scorpio vs Thar
Both SUVs feature advanced engines designed for performance and durability. The Scorpio’s mHawk diesel engine is renowned for its refinement and power, making it perfect for highways and city commutes. The Thar’s turbocharged engines excel at delivering instant power, especially off-road.
Tyres and Brakes Scorpio vs Thar
The Scorpio’s tyres are optimised for stability on the road, while the Thar’s all-terrain tyres and excellent braking system make it a clear winner for adventure enthusiasts. Whether you’re driving on rocky roads or sandy dunes, the Thar’s tyre and brake combination ensures confidence.
Safety Features Scorpio vs Thar
| Feature | Mahindra Scorpio | Mahindra Thar |
| Airbags | Dual (Base), Up to Six (Top Models) | Dual Airbags Standard |
| Braking System | ABS with EBD | ABS with EBD |
| Digital Speedometer | Traditional with Modern Touches | Fully Digital Cluster |
| Strong Chassis | Reinforced for Durability | Ladder-Frame for Tough Terrains |
Airbags
- Scorpio: Dual airbags in the base variant and up to six in the top model.
- Thar: Dual airbags are standard across all variants.
Braking System
- Both vehicles come with ABS and EBD, which ensure controlled braking even on slippery surfaces.
Digital Speedometer
- The Scorpio has a more traditional design with a modern touch, while the Thar’s digital cluster adds a contemporary vibe.
Strong Chassis
- Both models boast of a robust chassis, with the Thar’s ladder-frame design built to withstand tough terrains.
Price Scorpio vs Thar
| Price | Mahindra Scorpio | Mahindra Thar |
| Ex-Showroom Price | ₹12.5 – ₹20 lakhs | ₹10.5 – ₹16 lakhs |
| On-Road Price | ₹15 – ₹22 lakhs | ₹12 – ₹18 lakhs |
Ex-Showroom Price
- Scorpio: Starting at approximately ₹12.5 lakhs.
- Thar: Starting at around ₹10.5 lakhs.
On-Road Price
- Scorpio: Goes up to ₹20 lakhs for top variants.
- Thar: Maxes out at around ₹16 lakhs, depending on the configuration.
- Budget Perspective: Thar is the more affordable option, especially for entry-level variants.
Final Verdict Scorpio vs Thar
In the Scorpio vs Thar showdown, the choice boils down to your specific needs:
- Choose the Scorpio if you prioritize comfort, family-friendly features, and highway performance.
- Opt for the Thar if you crave adventure, off-road capability, and a rugged, iconic design.
Both SUVs embody Mahindra’s legacy of durability and performance, ensuring you can’t go wrong with either choice.
Which Mahindra giant would you pick? Share your thoughts in the comments below and let us know if you’ve experienced the thrill of driving these SUVs!
